June25
This was written for a Welsh Pony list I belong to, but once I speand this much time at a key board, I want to share it. ….or misery loves company… LOL
Nothing like discussing breeding with someone who’s done horse rescue since before the term was coined! LOL I love the process, the foals, the decisions behind it, selection of the perfect match. That being said, my valuable, rare breed mares (the Welsh I don’t breed, just ride/train) with valuable foals remain open this year. I’ll use the time to prove them out more, get ready for inspections, IBOP (A performance test) and dressage and eventing competition.
First off, I’m guess that I didn’t read the post about supporting the registry correctly. <G> I can’t imagine breeding to pay/support a registry, it would be better to make donations – and cheaper then feeding! But as I DO deal with a rare breed that has come back in numbers, I have to address the declining numbers issue.
Most horses, not picking on Welsh here, I believe it to be all breeds, have lines that should die out. Sadly, it never seems to happen. So the same holds possibly true in reverse, that some of the valuable lines will survive until numbers reach the endangered level – which I CAN’T see happening with welsh. Shetlands have more limited use and the fine harness/saddle type market took a hit which affected many breeds. Arabians will survive because they make great dressage or endurance horses, Morgans can adapt as well – trying to sell the breeds for profit’s not likely, but they won’t go away with this trend. Shetlands, well, I’m biased, but let’s just say I bought welsh ponies for my girls???? <G>
Welsh are more usable for adults as well, more versatile, are sensible, attractive, and the only competition for a lot of what they do is pricey imported riding ponies. Oh, wait, I have a pricey, imported (sort of, Canada) Welsh… hmmm. LOL As a dressage/sport horse person, I can’t see the Welsh ever going out of favor. Peaks and valleys in popularity happens to all breeds, but popularity is more damaging, IMO…
There are special quality lines that must be protected from dieing out, I do agree, but breeding to keep a line alive, well, if so few people want them, then just a few knowledgeable people maintaining a select group is very appropriate.
Secondly, the economy hype is only one factor regarding the horse market’s drop. The significant loss of hay fields (aside from development and the usual loss of agriculture land, the NW was getting government subsidies to take hay fields and put them into corn crops for ethanol, of I heard from a reliable hay farmer $1500 an acre) and price gouging of hay (yes, gas costs were high, but we experienced a 300-400% increase in hay prices in 2 YEARS – nothing can account for that, and I grew up bucking hay, my dad custom bales, so I know what work and time goes into it. This is not a guess on my part!) has made the price of keeping a horse SKYROCKET.
The other factor, near and dear to my heart, is the closing on US slaughter houses. These houses enabled irresponsible breeders (I have some amazing pictures of leg flaws in horses bred purely because they had ‘color’ for example, totally irresponsible breeding,a nd it’s common) to still harvest CASH for their unwanted and unusable horses. OTTBs as well – we have a auction near a race track nd I often went to pick up really really nice TBs for dressage and eventing – I retrained as many as I could, beautiful, SOUND, talented horses who were just to slow, to prevent them form being meat.
On the subject of meat, i am all for sensible recycling of horse life, I’m not anti eating horses. I am anti-enabling and anti-cruel conditions, suffering and pain PRE-SLAUGHTER. The shipping laws are well publicized for being ignored.
Anyway, I don’t want to start an argument because there are always pro-slaughter people and we each have our own views If you are going to reply to this, remember to keep it polite! I love disagreements, they make me grow, just not attacks….
Several times have been told how nice and comfy the slaughtering process is for horses! But check out my poorly neglected blog for some more info: http://elijahpark.com/blog/?p=34 ….never did get to that article, BAD me!
SO, my breeding ethic in a good market is this: Do I have a purpose? Will it improve the breed or preserve a status quo (or in the rare case of the best of the best mare crossed with good stallion, preserving the standard of perfection, status quo is okay! But few horses attain the standard of perfection, being realistic about the inevitable flaws in good horses is mandatory for breeding) and what life will it head to?
Who will provide it a home? Just breeding for numbers, foals to sell in general, so-so mares of good bloodline but never used or proven, to champion stallions I believe to be unethical. We try to prove out our mares, riding, showing, getting inspected, the same as a stallion.
Mares contribute 70% of the dna, albeit a prepotent stallion can override that visibly as breeders know, but the mare’s selection seldom gets anywhere near the attention a stallion’s does. “Okay, I have X mare, who will be the best cross” isn’t okay. It should be “I have X mare, why should she be bred? What does SHE offer? only then should we consider a positive stallion match. I hear a lot of ‘but I’m breeding for myself”. Well, there are a lot of quality foals better then yours lily will be for cheaper then your breeding costs. they cost the same to feed, so why not get the better horse? Sentiment is a powerful thing and behind too much breeding choices, I suspect.
And breeding in this environment? This is the first year many of those oblivious irresponsible breeders (I am NOT being personal, because the mere fact that you are here on the list excludes you – I’m talking the toss ‘em some hay, chew on wood for the extra, wear big spurs and always use a tie-down environment) realize they aren’t getting money for their horses. The horse collectors have been having a ‘hay day’ (until the hay runs out). Kind hearted but illogical rescues have been getting in over their heads and needing rescuing. So I’m holding off totally one more year. At least. <G>
Good heavens, are you still reading? Congratulate yourself for your fortitude. Then go get some fresh (lightly horse manure scented counts) air!